Discover Jimmy's Ice Cream in Cresco, PA, serving generous portions of soft serve, hard ice cream, sundaes, shakes, and their famous banana split. A local favorite offering quality treats in a cash-only shop next to Mountain Home Diner. Perfect for a refr
Jimmy's Ice Cream, nestled in the quiet charm of Cresco, PA, offers a refreshing retreat for ice cream lovers looking for classic, no-frills treats. Located at 916 PA-390, this local gem serves up both soft serve and hard ice cream with a focus on generous portions and familiar flavors. The highlight of their menu is undoubtedly the Banana Split, a nostalgic favorite that embodies the simple pleasures this shop excels in delivering.
The experience at Jimmy's is warm and welcoming, largely thanks to the attentive crew who handle both register and service with genuine friendliness. Whether you’re stopping by on a hot summer afternoon or finishing off a meal next door at the Mountain Home Diner, Jimmy’s complements the local dining scene perfectly. The diner provides a full meal experience, while Jimmy's covers the dessert cravings, making this pairing a convenient stop for families and travelers alike.
Jimmy’s Ice Cream caters to a broad audience—from kids seeking a classic cone to adults craving a rich sundae or a lush shake. The shop offers a variety of options including soft serve, sundaes, shakes, and even “arctic swirls,” where popular toppings like Oreos or Reese’s cups are blended right in. For those wanting something lighter, Italian water ice enhances the choice available.
Space-wise, Jimmy’s retains a modest, down-to-earth vibe, emphasizing quality and quantity over fancy décor or an extensive flavor list. While some might wish for a wider variety of flavors, the selection is straightforward and satisfying. The shop operates on a cash-only basis, which adds a small rustic touch, though it requires some planning for visitors. Pricing is fair and portions are ample, making it a budget-friendly stop.
Although no longer owned by Jimmy himself, the commitment to tasty, satisfying ice cream remains steadfast. This spot is ideal for those seeking comfort in classic dessert offerings without pretension—perfect for locals and visitors exploring the Pennsylvania countryside who want a sweet pause in their day.
